When I was in Catholic school some seventy years ago, our teacher would occasionally have to be out of the room for a while. We did not have substitutes. Rather the nuns would send one of the eighth-grade girls down to monitor while they were away. Their instructions were to write the names of any pupils who misbehaved on the blackboard. When the sister returned, the troublemaker would face the consequences.
One afternoon, a girl named Diane was to watch over us first and second graders for an hour or so. Diane was a nice responsible girl, but she happened to have a rather large nose. Kids that age can be cruel and I was no exception. I whispered a comment about Diane’s appearance to one of my friends who giggled out loud. Now, my observation was not intended to be shared with anyone else. I certainly would not have made my remark to Diane.
A short time later, the principal stopped in to check on our behavior. Debbie, our class tattletale, stood up and in front of Diane said, “Richard said she has a nose like a banana.” In my defense, that is not even close to what I said, not that my actual comment was any more flattering. The principal made me come up in front of the class where she stared me down. Through weepy eyes, I denied the accusation. Sister looked me in the eye for a few seconds without saying a word. Then she told me to go sit down, and told Debbie she needed to keep her mouth shut.
I can look back on things I said to others during my early years that were hurtful, and deeply regret those words today. Discretion comes with maturity, or at least it should. Maturity means keeping all those immature thoughts to oneself. They will still happen. Our minds are constantly forming opinions. As responsible adults, we should know when to speak up and when to be quiet. Unfortunately, that is not always the case especially when it comes to social media.
We base our opinions on facts that we believe to be true, or want to believe are true. But we seldom have all the facts, and when we don’t, we fill the gaps with assumptions that may or may not be factual. Keeping that in mind, we must acknowledge that our opinions may need adjustment from time to time, and would be wise to keep most of them to ourselves. The anonymity of the internet has made voicing opinions a preoccupation for many, especially those lacking the wisdom to be quiet.
Before the internet and social media, people generally had to take responsibility for their own words. Anonymous letters were tossed in the waste basket. Newspapers would not print unsigned letters on the editorial page. Occasionally names would be withheld, but the publisher still required a signature. Messages from those hiding their identity were generally disregarded with the possible exception of ransom notes.
Today, anyone can create a username and say anything they want to the whole world. They call it free speech, but it should come with accountability. Hiding one’s identity to avoid backlash from unpopular comments is cowardly. The advent of artificial intelligence further complicates the matter. Much social media commentary today does not have a human author to take responsibility.
Seems to me that people should be required to stand behind any comments they make publicly. Just as editorial boards once required signatures before publishing a letter, people who post on internet public forums should be named. Any posting generated by artificial intelligence should be labelled as such with the instigator identifiable. Postings that are monetized should be designated as such. Say what you want, but show your face.